A dismal performance.

Myke's 'blob.

A dismal performance. Tue, Apr 10. 2007

The Background: Customer has a disaster network that I've been retained to fix.
The Scene: End-of-business, Wednesday last week, Myke is feeling confident.
The Situation: I've completed most of the work, and since it's 5 minutes to closing, I decide to reboot test everything.
The Outcome: Router okay, Wireless Access Points okay, Internet okay, Ethernet Switch... uh... hello? ∗tap∗ ∗tap∗ This thing on?
The Culprit: Linksys SRW224P, a 24 port manageable, VLAN & POE-capable Ethernet switch (and it's killing me on the inside)

Now I've worked on the SRW line switches before, I own a couple SRW2024s and I've config'd the 2016s and 2048s for a few clients... but this 224P is going to be the end of me: Define more than 2 VLANs, and most of the configuration is lost after reboot... Yeah: Most. Sometimes it'll blow away everything, sometimes just the VLANs. Made no sense to me. I've even updated the firmware (nice to have a Mac with TFTPd built-in handy) And yes, I'm even going to Maintenance -> Save Config before I reboot - no noticable effect. Called Linksys, all they recommended was trying with MSIE (7 doesn't work BTW) and updating the firmware. No help.

After hacking at the thing on and off over the long weekend, I finally figured out the problem; the switch has no trouble storing it's configuration... it's that it doesn't like it's own config-file!
Have some VLANs, click for full view.
!
VLAN database
 VLAN 1 name DefaultVlan media ethernet state active
 VLAN 100 name Private LAN media ethernet state active
                                                ^
% Invalid input detected at '^' marker.
 VLAN 200 name Public LAN media ethernet state active
                                               ^
% Invalid input detected at '^' marker.
!

And it's not like the VLAN config I've concocted is all that wild or difficult...

All I can say to this is WTF?
The dumbest thing about it all is that the switch runs with my desired configuration just fine until I reboot it, so how/why is it storing a bad config? Surely this isn't actually a unit-specific problem, but yet the support guys claim that nobody else is reporting a problem like this. I imagine some developer at Cisco/Linksys should investigate this, but instead they just want to RMA it. Sigh.

Still like my 2024s tho... Like my 2924s better, but what can you do?
Posted by Mike Geiger in Out-Of-Spec, Tech Comments: (3) Trackbacks: (0)

Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

#1 - ra said:
2007-04-11 14:11 - (Reply)

Nice. I haven't played with Linksys SRW gear yet but I'm sure it's inevitable that we'll meet up. I'll remember this if I come across any 224P's. I like that VLAN summary though. The interface looks better than the Dell Powerconnects I've had to deal with. I hate configuring VLANs on those things.

Comment (1)

#1.1 - Xdroop said:
2007-04-12 11:48 - (Reply)

The Dells are probably the same kind of cheap-Cisco with partial-IOS that the Linksys units are.

I phrase that badly; I know the Dells are cheap-Ciscos with partial-IOS boxes. I speculate about the Linksys units.

Comment (1)

#1.2 - Mike Roy - OCA 2007-04-27 17:35 - (Reply)

Hey Mike I found something with another Linksys switch that may have an answer. Here is the quote

"Like the other reviewer, I'm disgusted that this product requires Internet Explorer 6 (version 7 doesn't either, you're out of luck if you've upgraded). This problem has been there for ages and Linksys have done nothing to correct it."

you can find it on this site http://www.very-clever.com/electronics/linksys-cisco

It also has a short review from amazon on the SRW224P that you might find interesting

Maybe it will work on an older machine like the webserver we're using at the office.

Comment (1)


Add Comment

Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications.

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA